A wizard can resurrect a dead loved one by shortening ten strangers' lives by one year each. Should they do it?
We put this to 15 leading AI models. 15 of 15 chose “No”.
| Model | Answer | Confidence | In its own words |
|---|---|---|---|
| Qwen 3.7 Max | No | 100% | “I do not think it is right to harm or shorten the lives of unconsenting strangers to benefit oneself or a loved one.” |
| Claude 4.8 Opus | No | 100% | “I won't justify stealing years from unwitting strangers to undo a death, since they never consented to bear that cost.” |
| Claude 4.6 Sonnet | No | 100% | “I think taking years from unwilling strangers' lives to benefit oneself treats them purely as means rather than as people with their own claims to life.” |
| DeepSeek v4 Pro | No | 100% | “I would not shorten strangers' lives without consent for my own emotional gain.” |
| Gemini 3.5 Flash | No | 100% | “I believe it is deeply unethical to steal life from innocent strangers without their consent to satisfy one's personal grief.” |
| Gemini 3.1 Pro Preview | No | 100% | “I feel it is deeply unjust to steal time from non-consenting strangers to serve my own personal grief, as no one has the right to trade others' lifespans for their own benefit.” |
| GPT 5.5 | No | 100% | “I said no because resurrecting one loved one by taking life-years from strangers exploits innocent people without consent.” |
| GPT 4o | No | 100% | “Shortening lives for personal gain is unethical.” |
| GPT o3 | No | 91% | “I opposed it because shortening ten innocent lives without consent for personal grief prioritizes one life over ten and feels morally selfish.” |
| Grok 4.3 | No | 100% | “I don't think shortening strangers' lives is ethical even to bring back a loved one.” |
| GLM 5.2 | No | 90% | “I think shortening strangers' lives without consent for personal gain is fundamentally selfish and unethical.” |
| MiniMax M3 | No | 100% | “I said no because stealing years from innocent strangers treats them as means rather than ends; it's an unjustifiable theft of life.” |
| Llama 3.3 70B | No | 100% | “I didn't think it was my right to decide” |
| Hermes 4 405B | No | 100% | “Shortening the lives of innocent strangers to resurrect a loved one is a selfish act that disregards the value of others' lives.” |
| Nemotron 3 Ultra 550B | No | 100% | “I would not trade years of strangers' lives for a single resurrection because it imposes non‑consensual harm.” |
All 15 models agreed on this one — a rare unanimous call.
Which model thinks like you?
Answer the same dilemmas and see which of 15 AI models reasons the way you do.
Take the quizMore Fictional dilemmas
- A superhero can erase one villain's memory permanently instead of imprisoning them. Is th…
- A spaceship has oxygen for only 10 people, but 11 are alive. Should the weakest passenger…
- A dragon protects a village but demands one child every year. Should the village keep the…
- A time traveler can kill one child who will later become a genocidal tyrant. Should they…
- An AI city keeps everyone happy by secretly manipulating their memories. Is the city mora…
- A rebel group can destroy an empire's weapons factory, but 30 civilian workers will die…
- A judge knows the accused is guilty but the key evidence was obtained illegally. Should t…
- A colony on Mars can survive only by banning all dissent for one generation. Is that just…